Crossroad Springs follows the Hamilton family siblings James and Janet, their father Willis, and Aunt Amy, who are struggling to keep the family ranch afloat amid financial hardships and staffing shortages. James, a pastor in Chicago, and Janet, a doctor in a nearby town, return home to help, only to find old tensions stirred by a long-standing feud with the neighboring Newman family. As James adjusts to ranch life, he recognizes the need for a place of worship in the community and begins a cowboy church where faith, family, and ranch life come together.